Second Opinions
A couple of weeks ago I did something out of character. After being told by my oncologist that we needed to switch chemo drugs (my latest CT scan showed significant tumor growth), I challenged his decision. I had three reasons for this. The first was that Doxil, the drug I had been taking for the last 4 months has a reputation for being slow to kick in. The second was a personal observation that my abdomen had recently begun to flatten slightly. The third was my latest CA-125 tumor marker blood test - it had dropped 490 points in three weeks. A CA-125 test is never as accurate as a scan, but in this case I thought the drop in numbers suggested a turnaround. Maybe the Doxil was slow to get started - hence the tumor growth that showed up on the scan - but was now at last “kicking in”.
So I asked for a second opinion. My doctor’s response to the request (conveyed through his nurse) was gracious. Of course it was completely understandable, he said. His nurse then set up an appointment with another doctor in the practice. (I didn’t have time at this point to go outside of the practice without significantly delaying my next infusion.)
After what seemed like a good start, things started to go downhill a bit. The doctor I was scheduled to see for a second opinion seemed more like someone who would put a rubber stamp on my doctor’s first opinion.
Sadly, this turned out to be true. When we met, the first words out of her mouth were that she and my doctor had been working together for 20 years and they almost always saw eye to eye on patient treatment recommendations. Hmmm. Not an auspicious conversation opener for a second opinion. As the conversation went on it became clear that she was putting more effort into convincing me of the rightness of the first opinion than considering any other possibilities. For example, she tossed off my mention of the 490 point drop in tumor markers by saying that there could be a lot of reasons for this. In fact, she said, my chart showed that I had had my ascites fluid drained recently which reduces peritoneal inflammation. Less inflammation in the peritoneal cavity could cause the numbers to go down. I asked her to take another look at my chart - the date that the ascites fluid had been drained was after that of the CA-125 test, so that couldn’t be a cause.
She continued to make her case. Later in the conversation the CA-125 markers came up again and she repeated her statement about the ascites drain causing a drop in the numbers that would be unrelated to tumor activity. I indicated again that if she looked at the dates in my chart she would see that the ascites drain happened after the blood test and therefore couldn’t have affected it. Unbelievable.
After going back and forth like this for a while she said she would leave it up to me whether to continue with Doxil or switch to the new drug, a route she still favored. I asked for another CA-125 test to help me decide. When the test results came back later that day, they showed another drop of 410 points. Situation resolved. At least for this month, I would stay the course with Doxil.
But I guess the second opinion I asked for had to be my own.